Scorecards
One card per manifesto. Open a card to see every promise, its status and the evidence behind that status.
What the five statuses mean
Kept-or-broken is a headline, not an assessment. These five let us be accurate about the messy middle, which is where most promises live.
- Delivered
- The promised thing exists and is in operation, and a document outside the office's own press release shows it.
- Under way
- Work has visibly started — budget allocated, contract awarded, bill tabled — and is on a plausible path to completion.
- Stalled
- It started and then stopped: funds unspent, works abandoned, a bill that has not moved for a year or more.
- Abandoned
- The promise was dropped, reversed, or the term ended with no action we can find. Needs strong evidence.
- Can't verify
- We have the promise but no reliable evidence either way. This is an honest answer, and the default.
How we score a promise
Scoring promises is a judgement call, so here is ours in full. Disagree with a specific call and you will have the same documents we used.
- Only promises published in a manifesto or made on the record are scored.
- We quote the promise in the promiser's own framing, not a paraphrase that helps or hurts them.
- A status needs evidence from outside the office's own communications.
- A promise with no evidence either way is marked “Can't verify”, not “Abandoned”.
- Promises partly delivered are “Under way” or “Stalled” — we do not round them up to delivered.
- Every call carries the date it was last checked. Old checks go stale and get re-done.
VoteWise is non-partisan and takes no party's side. We publish the same rubric for every office holder we score, incumbent or opposition.
Where the evidence comes from
These are the public records we read. You can read them too — and tell us when we have got a call wrong.